Quantcast
Channel: PTC Community: Message List - Creo
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 11377

Re: Creo vs. Solidworks vs. Inventor

$
0
0

I am contemplating a new position that uses NX. 

And I am looking back at my experience in NX. 

Interesting thing... that experience is unremarkable! 

And that is a good thing.

 

As for Creo, there are a lot of little things PTC could have done over the years with nearly every command. 

Some they improved, and some they replaced with a half backed replica. 

Speaking solely about Creo, as a long time user; Creo -should be- a whole lot more than it is.

Yet, PTC decided their business model was to create optional extensions for what should have been included in the core product.  That - is my only gripe about Creo   ...that and the half-baked candy cane UI wrapper.

 

However, I see little comment on the detailing side of these 3 products.  Again, NX was unremarkable in my mind, yet Creo is pretty much the very same as Pro|E 18, 19, 2000i.  One improvement over the years... shaded views.  I see this as neglect.

 

I'm with Rohit on this.  My old 2000i seat simply worked.  The only crashes I had was from over-clicking and locking up the works.  Power or not, it was what I trained myself to use and I made a good living at it.  Modeling discipline is not required in Pro|E but very helpful for creating sustainable models.  And like so many others, I really did like the old XTOP interface.  It was efficient and organized. 

 

It is funny how this thread is likely the largest, longest, and most viewed thread on the forum.  And even for my own comments, it just keep going around and around.  It doesn't even have a real point to make.  But the nostalgia of it all is intriguing.

 

But to sum up this post, I -am- glad that I can open models I created 15 years ago without issue in Creo 2.0 and continue where I left off.  That is in fact a major feat.  PTC does deserve kudos for that.


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 11377

Trending Articles



<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>